Court of Appeal rules on Do Not Resuscitate orders

17 June 2014
The Court of Appeal has today ruled doctors must consult with and inform patients before placing a Do Not Resuscitate (DNR) order on their medical notes.

 The judgment makes law existing doctors' guidelines, which recommend consultation and involvement, and gives clarity to a sensitive subject which is raised at difficult times for patients, their families, carers and friends. The ruling follows a test case brought by the family of Hertfordshire woman, Janet Tracey, who were unhappy when a DNR notice was placed on her notes without consultation or discussion.

Claire Henry, chief executive of the National Council for Palliative Care, the lead charity of Dying Matters, commented: "We welcome the emphasis that the Court of Appeal has placed on involving people in decisions about their care. Although discussions on such sensitive issues are rarely easy, it is usually much better to involve and consult people than to exclude them for fear of causing upset.

"This ruling also underlines why we need a national conversation on dying, so that members of the public and healthcare professionals alike become more comfortable in talking openly about dying, death and bereavement and become better equipped to make difficult decisions about care and support at the end of life.”


Read the BBC news story on the test case.

Read the full judgement.

Not registered?

Register Now

Log in to post

Dying Matters Podcast

The first season of our podcast on all things deathly! 

Listen to the podcast

E-newsletter sign up

Getting the latest Dying Matters news delivered straight to your inbox.

Sign up today!


Which of the following describes how you would feel talking to someone close to you about their end of life wishes.

Share your event

Are you organising an event linked to death, dying or bereavement? Tell us what you're doing and we'll share it with our supporters. Add it to our Events Calendar now.

Share your event